Encapsulating Asbestos Textured Ceilings vs Removal: Costs, Pros & Cons Explained

Encapsulating Asbestos Textured Ceilings vs Removal

If you live in an older house, there’s a good chance that funky popcorn or textured ceiling might contain asbestos. When it comes time to fix it, you’ve got two choices: encapsulate it with paint or sealant, or go all in and remove the asbestos ceiling altogether. Both options have pros and cons, and the costs are miles apart. Let’s break it down so you can make the call.

What Is Encapsulation?

Encapsulation is basically locking asbestos fibres in place. A thick paint, sealant, or special coating is rolled or sprayed over the textured ceiling so the asbestos can’t break loose and float into the air. The asbestos stays there, but it’s trapped.

Pros of Encapsulation

  • Cheaper upfront – In New Zealand, encapsulating an asbestos ceiling can cost between $15–$35 per m², depending on the type of coating used.

  • Less invasive – No ripping down ceilings, no trucks hauling away dangerous waste. Tenants can often stay in the house while it’s done.

  • Quick turnaround – A skilled team can knock out a room in a day or two.

  • Lower risk during the job – Because the asbestos isn’t being disturbed, there’s less chance of fibres getting loose.

Cons of Encapsulation

  • Asbestos is still there – It doesn’t go away. You’re covering it, not removing it.

  • Future work is tricky – If you later want to renovate, install downlights, or run new wiring, the ceiling still has asbestos.

  • Might need re-doing – Coatings can crack or flake over time, meaning another job down the track.

  • Resale impact – Some buyers and property managers don’t like the idea of asbestos, encapsulated or not.

What About Removal?

Removal means bringing in a licensed asbestos removal company to scrape or strip out the ceiling, bag it up, and dispose of it at an approved facility. It’s the only way to get rid of asbestos for good.

Pros of Removal

  • Permanent solution – Once it’s gone, it’s gone. No worries about coatings wearing out.

  • Freedom for renovations – Install lights, repaint, or redesign without asbestos in the way.

  • Adds value – Buyers are more comfortable with a property that’s asbestos-free.

Cons of Removal

  • Expensive – In New Zealand, removal can cost anywhere from $60–$120 per m², sometimes more if the job is complex.

  • Disruption – Removal work is noisy, dusty (even with controls), and everyone has to vacate the house until clearance is given.

  • Higher risk during the process – Stripping asbestos makes it friable, so strict safety controls are required.

  • Waste disposal costs – Licensed disposal is pricey, and transport adds to the bill.

So Which Is Better?

If you’re on a budget, need the job done fast, and don’t plan on touching the ceiling again, encapsulation is the cheaper, safer short-term play.
If you’ve got renovation plans, want to boost property value, or simply don’t want asbestos hanging over your head, removal is the long-term fix.

Cost Snapshot (NZ estimates)

  • Encapsulation: $15–$35 per m²

  • Removal: $60–$120+ per m²

Final Word

Both encapsulation and removal of asbestos textured ceilings have their place. Encapsulation is cheaper and less disruptive, but asbestos stays put. Removal is costly and invasive, but it’s permanent. Before making a call, talk to a licensed asbestos removalist who can give you site-specific advice and a written quote.

Make Enquiry